Or Sign In With

Create an account and get $150 discount immediately!

Engagement Ring Appraisal Guide

Engagement Ring Appraisal Guide

Engagement Ring Appraisal

If you’ve never sold a piece of jewelry before or you’re not familiar with the engagement ring valuation process, appraisals can seem like a totally foreign concept. In all fairness, there is a lot of confusion about what appraisals mean, particularly when it comes to the initial cost of a ring and the potential resale value. While a diamond engagement ring appraisal will give you a general idea of how much your ring is worth, it will not guarantee that you will get the same price if you choose to resell your ring.

So, why do you need engagement ring appraisals? Will the appraisal value be lower for a used engagement ring? Finally, where can you buy and sell high-quality pre-owned engagement rings?

In today’s guide, we will answer all of these questions and more, but first, let’s take a look at how engagement rings are appraised:

How Engagement Rings Are Appraised

In order to appraise an engagement ring, professional appraisers and gemologists must evaluate the piece and assign a specific monetary value to it. The appraisal process is most often used to determine how much a ring is worth for insurance purposes, but it can also be used to let a seller know the potential resale value of their ring. Here are some of the basic steps involved in the appraisal process:

  1. Identifying the Materials - The appraisal begins with a basic evaluation of the materials present in the ring. This is particularly important for the band, which will most commonly contain gold, platinum, or silver. The type of material, as well as the weight and quality of the material, will be central components in the evaluation of the ring.

  2. Evaluating the Center Stone - Generally speaking, the center stone of an engagement ring accounts for a large portion of a ring’s value. The appraiser will need to consider the 4 C’s of diamonds during this process — cut, color, carat, and clarity.

  3. Assessing Additional Stones - If an engagement ring has additional stones (like accent stones), the appraiser will also evaluate their quality and value using the aforementioned criteria.

  4. Evaluating Craftsmanship and Design - The overall craftsmanship and design of a ring also play a crucial role in its appraisal value. While there is some subjectivity in this part of the process, appraisers will generally look at the intricacy of the setting and any unique or complex features in the design. 

  5. Checking for Certifications - The appraiser will look for any hallmarks or certifications that indicate the authenticity and quality of the ring. For instance, a diamond certified by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) will give a ring greater value, as it is guaranteed to be authentic.

  6. Calculating the Value - After examining all the factors above, the appraiser will calculate the value of the ring. They will typically provide a detailed report, including a description of the ring, an assessment of its components, and the final appraised value.

Where To Get An Engagement Ring Appraised

There are various places to get an engagement ring appraised without a significant delay. Some of the most common options include:

  • Local Jewelers - Some local jewelry stores offer appraisal services through a certified gemologist. Just be sure to do your research on the jewelers’ credentials beforehand and consider getting your ring appraised by multiple jewelers to see how the values compare.

  • Independent Appraisers - Independent jewelry appraisers specialize in evaluating different jewelry pieces. They do not buy or sell jewelry, which helps ensure an unbiased appraisal.

  • Gemological Laboratories - Established gemological institutions like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) offer some of the best appraisal services. These institutions have well-trained gemologists and advanced equipment for highly accurate evaluations. 

  • Online Appraisals - Some companies offer online appraisal services, where you can send your engagement ring to them via insured mail. They will evaluate the ring and send it back to you with the final appraisal. If you’re selling your ring through HYSTR, we include this service as a standard part of the selling process.

Can Your Engagement Ring Appraise For Less Than You Paid?

The short answer is yes — your engagement ring can be appraised for less than you paid for it. In fact, this is very common. Unless you bought a ring pre-owned or at a substantial discount through a private seller, there is a good chance that the appraised value will be substantially lower than the cost. Here are just a few reasons that you are likely to encounter this discrepancy:

  • Retail Markup - Jewelry stores almost always apply a markup to cover their overhead costs. This markup can be significant, leading to a higher retail price than the appraised value, which represents the replacement value of the ring. In some cases, you may find rings that have a 100% markup over the appraisal value. 

  • Market Fluctuations - The value of precious metals and gemstones can fluctuate due to ever-changing market conditions. If the market value of the materials used in your ring has decreased since your purchase, the appraised value might be lower than what you paid.

  • Subjectivity in Valuation - The process of appraising an engagement ring involves some degree of subjectivity. Different appraisers may have slightly different opinions, which can impact the final appraised value.

  • Brand Premium - Some high-end jewelry brands command a premium for their products due to their reputation and the perceived value of the brand. This premium may not be reflected in the appraised value, which focuses on the intrinsic value of the materials and craftsmanship.

Engagement Ring Appraisal Vs Cost Vs Resale Value

It’s easy to confuse the appraisal, cost, and resale value of a ring. However, it is very important to understand that these are three completely distinct concepts. Let’s take a closer look at each of these to better understand why the final numbers can differ so much:

  • Appraisal Value - The primary purpose of an appraisal is to establish the replacement value for insurance purposes, ensuring that you can replace the ring with a similar one if it is lost, damaged, or stolen. The appraisal only takes the craftsmanship and quality of materials into account when determining a ring’s value.

  • Cost - The cost refers to the price you pay when purchasing the ring from a retailer or jeweler. This price typically includes a markup to cover the retailer's overhead costs. The cost of the ring is usually higher than the appraised value and the resale value.

  • Resale Value - The resale value of an engagement ring is the price you can expect to receive if you sell the ring to another individual or a jeweler. Resale value is generally lower than the appraised value or the original cost because the ring is considered pre-owned. So, even if it is in perfect condition, you can generally expect to get less than the cost or appraisal value. However, as a seller, you may be able to take advantage of things like the brand premium to get better offers. 

Since it’s difficult to know how much you could get for a ring based on the cost and appraisal value, we recommend using our engagement ring price lookup tool to get an estimation of your ring’s resale value. 


We hope you enjoyed our engagement ring appraisal guide! Are you currently trying to sell a used engagement ring? If so, be sure to contact HYSTR today!

wedding ,proposing ,engagement rings

Recent Posts
Used Diamond Rings For Sale By Owner

Used Diamond Rings For Sale By Owner

Emerald Cut Diamond

Emerald Cut Diamond Guide

Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Free Shipping

Free Shipping for orders over $150

Money Back Guarantee

Within 30 days for an exchange.

Online Support

24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Flexible Payments

Pay with Multiple Methods