Or Sign In With

Create an account and get $150 discount immediately!

Affordable Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Items 181-200 of 886

  1. PRE-OWNED
    Piero Milano 18K Yellow Gold Diamond 0.80ct. tw. Ring Sz 7.25 (55.1) RIDI-109552-521
    $2,892.50 $4,227.50
  2. PRE-OWNED
    Damiani Fiocco 18K Rose Gold Diamond 0.33ct. tw. Statement Ring Sz. 7.25 20068762
    $2,714.40 $3,967.20
  3. PRE-OWNED
    Piero Milano 18K White Gold Diamond 0.91ct. tw. Ring Sz 6.25 RIDI-102409-395.394
    $2,038.40 $2,979.20
  4. PRE-OWNED
    Piero Milano 18K White Gold Diamond 0.91ct. tw. Ring Sz 7.25 RIDI-102411-397.398
    $2,038.40 $2,979.20
  5. PRE-OWNED
    Piero Milano 18K White Gold Diamond 0.97ct. tw. Ring Sz 7.25 RIDI-102413-399.432
    $2,038.40 $2,979.20
  6. PRE-OWNED
    Damiani 18K White Gold, Diamond 0.64ct. tw. Cluster Ring Sz. 6.25
    $2,020.20 $2,952.60
  7. PRE-OWNED
    Damiani 18K White Gold and Diamond 0.82ct. tw. Flower Statement Ring Sz. 5
    $4,028.70 $5,888.10
  8. PRE-OWNED
    Mimi Milano Boutique 18K White Gold, Amethyst and Diamond 1.14ct. tw. Statement Ring sz 6.5 A712B8AB
    $3,348.80 $4,894.40
  9. PRE-OWNED
    Bucherer Ruthenium Plated 18K White Gold, Blue Sapphire 2.30ct. tw., and Diamond Statement Ring sz. 7.25
    $2,585.70 $3,779.10
  10. PRE-OWNED
    Roberto Coin 18K Yellow Gold, Diamond 0.50ct. tw. Open Ring Sz. 7 2062160AY65X
    $4,756.70 $6,952.10
  11. PRE-OWNED
    Bucherer Rhodium Finished 18K White Gold, Blue Iolite 3.53ct. tw. Brilliant Cut Diamond 0.58ct. tw. Statement Ring sz. 7.5
    $2,460.90 $3,596.70
  12. PRE-OWNED
    Bucherer 18K White Gold and Diamond 1.06ct. tw. Band Ring sz. 6.5
    $2,679.30 $3,915.90
  13. PRE-OWNED
    Roberto Coin 18K White Gold, Diamond 0.52ct. tw. Wrap Ring Sz. 5.75 8882591AW65X
    $2,692.30 $3,934.90
  14. PRE-OWNED
    Roberto Coin 18K Rose Gold, Diamond 0.65ct. tw. Statement Ring Sz. 6.75 8882537AH65X
    $3,383.90 $4,945.70
  15. PRE-OWNED
    Zydo 18K White Gold, Blue Sapphire 1.90ct. tw. and Diamond 0.94ct. tw. Contrarier Ring sz. 6.5
    $2,866.50 $4,189.50
  16. PRE-OWNED
    Zydo 18K Yellow Gold Diamond and Coral Petal Ring Sz 7.5 46156
    $2,628.60 $3,841.80
  17. PRE-OWNED
    Assael 18K Yellow Gold and Titanium, Orange Sapphire 1.46ct. tw. and Golden South Sea Cultured Pearl 9.1mm Statement Ring
    $3,781.70 $5,527.10
  18. PRE-OWNED
    Roberto Coin Nabucco 18K White Gold Diamond 0.85ct. tw. Ring Sz 6.5 2062223AW65X
    $4,228.90 $6,180.70
  19. PRE-OWNED
    Zydo 18K White Gold Blue Sapphire 2.34ct. tw. and White Diamonds 0.65ct. tw. Cocktail Ring sz. 7
    $4,680.00 $6,840.00
  20. PRE-OWNED
    Damiani 18K White Gold and White Diamond 0.48ct. tw. Band Ring sz. 7
    $2,367.30 $3,459.90

Pre-owned Engagement Rings Under $5,000

There’s nothing more beautiful than finding the perfect engagement ring — except finding the perfect engagement ring for a fraction of the retail price! If you’re looking for affordable engagement rings under $5,000, be sure to browse our collection today.

#haveyouseenthering

Explore our Instagram for a glimpse into the captivating allure of our luxurious jewelry. Join us on this journey and be inspired by the epitome of refined beauty.

Free Shipping

Free Shipping for orders over $150

Money Back Guarantee

Within 30 days for an exchange.

Online Support

24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Flexible Payments

Pay with Multiple Methods

Consult with a Jewelry Specialist

Experience personalized guidance and expertise with our Consult with a Jewelry Specialist service. Our team of knowledgeable specialists is here to assist you in selecting the perfect piece, answering your questions, and offering tailored advice.

Book an appointment