Or Sign In With

Create an account and get $150 discount immediately!

Affordable Engagement Rings Under $5,000

Items 861-880 of 886

  1. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Platinum GIA Certified 1.11 Carat Princess Cut Engagement Ring Set
    $3,257.00 $8,900.00
  2. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Princess cut VS2, 14K white gold two-piece set with 39 diamonds, 5 DWT
    $3,550.00 $6,350.00
  3. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    18KYG Wedding Set 3 Stone Engagement Ring 4 Stone Band 1.19CT Total
    $4,900.00 $6,000.00
  4. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    1.51 round brilliant diamond engagement ring with diamond wedding band
    $4,300.00 $6,600.00
  5. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    3 Stone Engagement Ring, 11 Stone Wedding Band, White Gold
    $2,240.00 $3,200.00
  6. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    1.625 TCW - 1.00 CT ROUND LEO ARTISAN DIAMOND 14K WHITE GOLD SET
    $4,200.00 $8,350.00
  7. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    .8 carat Round Solitaire,14K white gold band & 1 carat diam. inhancer
    $4,200.00 $6,200.00
  8. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    2.12 Neil Lane engagment ring and matching 1/2 carat wedding band
    $3,875.00 $9,500.00
  9. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    .75 Carat Round Brilliant Engagement Ring with Matching Diamond Band
    $3,800.00 $5,249.00
  10. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    .82 C Pear Brilliant Cut, fancy light gray, SI1 wedding set
    $2,990.00 $5,000.00
  11. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Ashcroft&Oak diamond engagement ring with kay jewelers 10k gold band
    $2,100.00 $2,300.00
  12. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    1.52tcw Leo Diamond in a Neil Lane Setting with Matching Band
    $3,100.00 $5,150.00
  13. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Stunning ring for a true princess
    $2,800.00 $3,995.00
  14. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Princess Cut 0.82 Carat Engagement Ring Set 1.83tcw
    $4,800.00 $10,800.00
  15. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Stackable Wedding Ring Set
    $4,900.00 $6,500.00
  16. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    Vintage 0.60ct Cushion Cut Diamond Bridal Ring Set 14k Yellow Gold 1.25tcw
    $3,464.00 $6,464.00
  17. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    0.85ct Cushion Twisted Accents Diamond Bridal Set in 14k Rose Gold 1.50tcw
    $4,899.00 $6,899.00
  18. NATURAL DIAMOND
    PRE-OWNED
    2tcw Cushion With Princess Cut Diamond Wedding Ring Set
    $4,399.00 $6,399.00

Pre-owned Engagement Rings Under $5,000

There’s nothing more beautiful than finding the perfect engagement ring — except finding the perfect engagement ring for a fraction of the retail price! If you’re looking for affordable engagement rings under $5,000, be sure to browse our collection today.

#haveyouseenthering

Explore our Instagram for a glimpse into the captivating allure of our luxurious jewelry. Join us on this journey and be inspired by the epitome of refined beauty.

Free Shipping

Free Shipping for orders over $150

Money Back Guarantee

Within 30 days for an exchange.

Online Support

24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Flexible Payments

Pay with Multiple Methods

Consult with a Jewelry Specialist

Experience personalized guidance and expertise with our Consult with a Jewelry Specialist service. Our team of knowledgeable specialists is here to assist you in selecting the perfect piece, answering your questions, and offering tailored advice.

Book an appointment